When should I replace my toilet?

When Should You Replace a Toilet Instead of Repairing It?

While toilets can technically last for decades, several signs indicate it's time for replacement rather than repair:

• ✔ Frequent repairs: If you're calling a plumber repeatedly for the same toilet, the cost of repairs will eventually exceed replacement value.
• ✔ Constant clogging: Toilets manufactured before the mid-1990s often have inefficient flushing designs that are prone to clogging, regardless of proper use.
• ✔ Cracks in the porcelain: Hairline cracks in the tank or bowl can suddenly worsen and cause flooding or water damage. These can't be reliably repaired.
• ✔ Excessive water usage: Older toilets use 3.5–7 gallons per flush, while modern WaterSense models use only 1.28 gallons or less, potentially saving thousands of gallons annually.
• ✔ Wobbling or unstable toilet: This might indicate floor damage from a leaking seal, which could require toilet removal to repair properly.
• ✔ Visible mineral buildup: Severe mineral deposits in the siphon jet or rim holes can permanently affect flushing performance.
• ✔ Aesthetic concerns: Permanent staining, scratched surfaces, or outdated colors might warrant replacement during bathroom remodeling.

Modern toilets offer significant advantages in water efficiency, flushing power, comfort (chair height and elongated bowls), and features like soft-close lids and more effective trapways. Our plumbers can help you select the right toilet for your needs and provide professional installation with proper sealing to prevent leaks.